Meet Josh | Josh Bartolotta Homes

Josh Bartolotta is a Rochester, NY real estate agent with over 18 years of experience and more than $165 million in career residential real estate sales. Consistently ranked among the top 1–2% of agents in the Rochester area, Josh is known for his strategic approach, meticulous attention to detail, and deep understanding of the local market. He works closely with buyers and sellers throughout Rochester and the surrounding suburbs, guiding every transaction from start to finish to ensure a smooth and successful experience. Josh has earned 41 five-star client reviews across Google and Zillow, reflecting his commitment to exceptional service and results.

A proud Rochester native, Josh graduated with honors from St. John Fisher University with degrees in Communications and Journalism and a minor in Spanish. Prior to entering real estate, he spent several years living in Los Angeles and New York City pursuing acting before returning home to Rochester. Outside of real estate, Josh enjoys spending time with his wife Sarah and their two sons, Cameron and Ryan. He is an avid sports fan who rarely misses an opportunity to cheer on the Buffalo Bills, New York Yankees, or Syracuse basketball.

Working with Josh

Josh attributes his success to the meaningful, genuine relationships he builds with his clients. He believes that open and honest communication is key to offering personalized service and providing the best advice at every stage of the real estate process. While guiding clients to find their perfect home or successfully selling a property is rewarding, what Josh values most are the lasting connections that develop over time. He is driven by a passion for improving his clients' lives, helping them find homes that bring both joy and fulfillment.

We were incredibly impressed by the immediate support [Josh] provided us. The attention and care he gave to us made it feel like we were his only client. We quickly grew to trust him which was important to us in navigating a complicated market. Once we had an offer accepted on a new house, he remained attentive and walked us through every step of the home buying process. We quickly listed our house and he gave us expert advice that I believe made all the difference in our sale. There’s a reason he’s a top realtor in our area!

Samantha Ferrin